Categories
Chart RealtyStocks

Sorry State of Realty Stocks

(Source Ramgopal25 Via LordLudus)

BNONpalCMAE6nkG.png large

Categories
Observations Realty RealtyStocks

Why analyzing Indian realty stocks is a waste of time

I came across this article where a brokerage firm does a “Realty Stock Check”-which realty stocks to buy/hold.Found it fairly amusing that there was no “sell” in the title.

Brokerages tend to treat the realty business like any other business.But do they seriously believe that the balance sheet/p&l statements of a realtor reflect the true state of affairs?

Cold hard cash is the mother’s milk which runs the realty business in India.You need cash to buy the land (no land owner will settle for 100% white), you need cash to pay off the contractors,you need cash to manage the politicians, you need cash to manage the officials etc

In Mumbai, builders routinely pay a couple of crores even before construction starts.

When such a large part of the realty business is done off the books,then does looking at the balance sheet etc make any sense?

Realty stocks can be a good medium for speculation/punting.But if you want to make real money from realty, forget the stock and research the hard asset.

Categories
5Stocks Tea

Plantation Stocks had a lousy May 2013

This post is in continuation of my 5 Stocks Series (see here)

Plantation (Tea) stocks which had a lousy May 2013 are given below :

Symbol Close on 30 April, 2013 Close on 31 May, 2013 Loss
MCLEODRUSS 313.15 294.65 -5.91%
HARRMALAYA 46.55 42.15 -9.45%
JAYSREETEA 95.05 83.85 -11.78%
WILLAMAGOR 38.05 33.45 -12.09%
ROSSELLIND 39 34 -12.82%
ASSAMCO 5.4 4.6 -14.81%
Categories
5Stocks Rail Stocks

Rail Wagon Stocks are having a terrible 2013

This post is in continuation of my 5 Stocks Series (see here).

Rail Wagon Stocks are having a terrible time this year as the table below indicates:

Symbol Close on 31 Dec, 2012 Close on 18 April, 2013 Loss
TEXRAIL 66.00 49.95 -24.32%
KALINDEE 101.80 49.45 -51.42%
TWL 358.70 169.1 -52.86%
CEBBCO 92.60 29.95 -67.66%

 

Categories
RealtyStocks

Realty Stocks:A revisit to Crisil’s picks

In an earlier post, I had blogged about Crisil having a webinar on realty stocks on 19th Dec, 2012 and had enclosed their report as well.

Crisil had made a strong buy recommendation on these stocks and it would be interesting to see how their picks performed Vs the Market.

The table below indicates the performance (19th Dec, 2012-22nd Jan, 2013)

Nifty: + 2%

Ashiana: -6.5%

Bhartiya: +3.6%

Niteshest: -20%

Parsvnath:-7%

Phoneixltd:-1%

Would track these picks on a 1/3/6/12 month basis just to see how they fared over a year